Concept:
The position of the sun on the horizon at sunrise and sunset changes as the year progresses. The position of the observer can determine how different people "see" the same natural event.
The Scientific Investigation:
How do different people in different locations "see" the same natural event?
Purpose:
This activity is designed to illustrate that different people can "see" the same natural event differently depending on their geographic location and to try to record and compare some of those similarities and differences.
Materials:
Drawing paper and pencils
Camera with date marker and/or video camera, if possible
Student worksheets (Spanish)
Procedure:
- Ask students to find a place at home to observe either the sunrise or sunset daily for one week or more. Take care that the sun really is n the horizon, and not rising over a mountain or hill. It would be way to bright to look at then. If this activity is done near the solstices, the students will probably not observe much difference in rising or setting time of the sun. Emphasize to the students to find a comfortable place where they do not expect to be interrupted so that they can record their observations daily. Students will record astronomical, meteorological, and other observations. (See student record sheet.) All students should be encouraged not only to write down their observations, but also to make a drawing of the sunrise/sunset each day, paying attention to the location on the horizon, location of trees and other landmarks, and the moon and stars if visible. If possible students could take a series of still photos (some cameras have a date marker) every day. If a video camera is available, then students could create a sequential video of each sunrise/sunset.
- After a week or more of collecting observations, have the students share their observations either as a class or in small groups. Break groups into sunrise and sunset observations.
- Have the students write an essay summarizing the different personal observations of their group. Was there a consensus that the sun position moved along the horizon or not? Did the time of sunrise or sunset change over this period? What were some of the commonalities and differences of their other observations? Why is it important to record detailed notes when doing observations?
- As a class, now summarize the observations into two reports which will be telecommunicated, one for sunrise and one for sunset. Include the astronomical and meteorological observations. Finally, create a list of key words presented in the student reports and observation records.
- Select some of the best drawings, photos, and/or videos and mail them to one of your partner schools. You may want to create one portfolio for all your partnered schools and mail it around to each school.
Students should report the following information to "The Group" involved in the project on a daily or weekly basis.
- School, City, State.
- Change in time of sunrise/sunset from previous day.
- Change in location of sunrise/sunset from previous day.
- Description of the moon.
- Description of other stars.
- Description of weather conditions.
Conclusion:
How do different people in different locations see the same natural event? How did the students attempt to describe their own personal observations? Were students actually able to observe together the same natural event? How different were the responses of individual students to this collective experience? How many used only verbal descriptions? How many used only drawings? Did anyone use music or dance to describe their personal observations? How freely were the students able to share their own personal feelings about how sunrises and sunsets influence them?
Assessment:
Scientists work in a very methodical fashion. Maintaining accurate records of observations and measurements is a key component in this systematic method. Every student should keep accurate chronological record, possibly in a scientific investigations journal or science lab book, of everything which they do in the investigation. These notes should be placed within the student's portfolio for assessment purposes.
As students increase in their awareness that different people "see" the same natural event differently, they may well increase the detail which they use to express their own observations. Writings and drawings summarizing what the student has observed should be included within the student's portfolio. Who else "sees" it like me? Who "sees" it differently? An analysis or comparison to other students' viewpoints might also be included in the portfolio.
Assessment of the quality of the student's work should respond to a rubric. This assessment tool describes how the level of involvement and completeness of a student's work will be related to the evaluation they will receive for the portfolio. Refer to a sample of a rubric included at the conclusion of these lessons.
Extensions
Science Investigations/Activities:
How is the position of the sun at sunrise and sunset related to the climatic environmental variables in the community? Have students design an experiment which organizes the following task. Students should determine a position on the horizon which represents "true" east (angle 090), and "true" west (270), as opposed to magnetic angles or "compass" angles, both of which are influenced by local variations or deviations of a true compass reading. Once the location on the horizon representing 090 and 270 have been determined, the student should measure the angle north or south of 090 and 270 for sunrise and sunset respectively. Times for sunrise and sunset should be measured, and the length of the day calculated from these measures. Measures of temperature (lowest and highest for the day from a maximum/minimum thermometer), and observations related to wind (speed and direction), clouds, and precipitation should also be noted.
Mathematics:
The student should proceed to statistically analyze the day-length, temperature, wind, cloud, and precipitation observations.